Justice A La Carte

Every week in the United States, innocent men are sentenced to death, either directly by lethal injection or indirectly by being given prison terms far longer than any human's natural life. Every week in the United States, rapists, murderers and child molesters are set free on technicalities, hung juries and smooth lawyering.

However, for almost every week, no one does anything about it.

The reason is that we have a justice system in place. It is imperfect, as is any system run by human beings, but it is there for a reason and it has a set of rules that it has to follow. Order must be preserved, the rule of law must be followed and, most importantly, everyone must be equal before the eye of the court.

Of course, we all understand that, in reality, not everyone is equal before the court and the recent Terri Schiavo only further illustrates that fact.

Simply put, Mrs. Shiavo's parents have something that no rape victim or innocent death row inmate will ever have, an act of congress to give them one more shot at getting the verdict they want.

For anyone else in the country, the case would be settled. Mrs. Shiavo's parents have had their day in court, many of them in fact, and have consistently lost as judge after judge has found in favor of Mrs. Shiavo's husband. Under current law, the case had gone as far as it could and was, in effect, over.

But Congress, like many Americans, decided it didn't like the verdict and was vocal about it, which is a fundamental right of every American. However Congress, unlike the rest of America, decided that it was going to do something about it and that it had the authority to intervene directly.

In effect, our legislature bent the laws governing the separation of powers and gave Terri's parents a “do over”. More to the point, they kicked the case over to federal court, even after a federal judge had repeatedly said he didn't have jurisdiction over the matter, effectively twisting the judicial system in a bid to get the verdict they want.

Yes, the Shiavo case deals with some difficult issues and, yes, the outcome of it is uneasy, as is any outcome in such a matter. However, that is what judges are for, to listen to the facts, look at the law, consider the best interest of the party involved and make difficult decisions in very charged cases. Not every verdict is loved or even liked, but that is no excuse for people who know little about the facts of the case to step in and undermine the system.

What makes the Shiavo case so different isn't that there was an unpopular verdict, but rather, that it deals with a politically charged issue and has spent so much time in the news. It's no longer about Shiavo, her family or even the right to die, it's about politicians looking good for the voters, even if it means ignoring nation-wide problems, bending constitutional limitations on their power and overruling judges who know far more about the case than they.

Congress' job, supposedly, is to make laws, not enforce them. However, they've sent a clear message that, if they don't get the verdict they like in a controversial case, they'll just keep using their powers until they either get the verdict they like or they run out of judges to put it in front of.

Worse still, the federal judge who gets the case has a clear idea of what verdict Washington D.C. wants and his position is directly appointed by the President with approval from Congress. Like an employee critical of his boss' plan, he has no chance of being impartial because his livelihood is on the line.

But perhaps the greatest injustice of all is that, if Congress is so hell-bent on using its power to manhandle the justice system, there are plenty of cases where justice was clearly denied. Given all of the times the justice system has obviously failed us, a series of Florida judges making unpopular decisions in a very difficult and controversial case seems rather minor.

In the end, this is an abuse of power in the worst possible way. It's a bending of the constitution, a trampling of our judicial system and a thumb to the eye of every citizen denied justice. All for a case with no easy answer and no hope for a happy ending.

No one can find justice when the judicial system is undermined and those who undermine it have forsaken the ideals it was founded upon. However, that's exactly the situation we're heading for if this type of bullying is allowed to continue.

Because, as imperfect as our justice system is, we have to let it work. Piecemeal justice means justice for none but those who are somehow deemed worthy. There's no way for everyone to be equal in such an environment and equality, supposedly, is our most cherished value of all.

This entry was posted in RavenSpeak. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Justice A La Carte

  1. NecromanticAngel says:

    This is very sadly true but maybe that's how the "art" of politics goes.

  2. Shelly says:

    I live in Tampa and I am sick of hearing all about Terri. This poor woman should have passed on long ago. I am also upset that Governor Bush overstepped his authority and butted in where he does not belong. Just because he is the President's brother Jeb Bush thinks he can get away with anything he wishes!

  3. sam says:

    Isn't it interesting that this case gets this amount of attention from the government, after Million Dollar Baby wins critical acclaim?

  4. "uncle eric" says:

    Very nice. Could not have said it any better.

  5. DragonKith says:

    Greetings All

    I totally agree with everyone on the subject about Terri i think she would be in a better place and she wouldnt be suffering and being in any forms of pain which her home state is putting her through etc. Hey everyone has their own view on life and death sitution i guess.Back here in Ohio once you turn on the tv they start talking about Terri on and on and on i am like saying change to a different subject already for crying out loud …..

  6. Norm says:

    Well, I don't believe that this case is the same as other cases and thats why it was in the eye of the media, this case has been big for a long time but something spurred the public to want to see the outcome of the case.

    What i think is odd is those who cry "enough already," who seem to be apathetic towards everything in life. Those who care and have opinions one way or the other are the ones who will define this Nation; While the Majority Sits back and Cries "Enough already Change the subject, I wanna see some action". And willingly accepts what they are given.

    Next I dont feel this case went over board by any means and I also feel there are many ties to what is happening in the world and our ties t—
    sorry I made up my mind I wont post anymore if i dont agree it takes too much time sorry i didn't finish but if i see something I really need to correct I will let you know

  7. karrah says:

    this is the only legal system we have until someone comes up with a better on get over it. what about those who deserve the needle. are you going to voice their wrongs as well?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.